Results of the Winter, Spring, and Summer LEGO® Reviews

It’s been a busy summer for us. We’re finally able to share the results of not one but three review periods: Winter 2012, Spring, and Summer 2013. We’ve looked closely at each of the ten projects in this these review periods, and here is what we have decided:

LEGO CUUSOO #006: Exo Suit

We’re thrilled to take Peter Reid’s original Exo Suit concept and create a LEGO® set based on it. The set is now in development, which means professional LEGO designers are creating the final version that will become the LEGO CUUSOO set. Final design, pricing, and availability are still being determined, and we’ll reveal the final product leading up to its release in 2014.

Exo Suit - Fan Submission, Not Final Product

We’re still evaluating the Land-Rover Defender 110

We’re still in the process of evaluating the Land-Rover Defender 110 by Sheepo. We’ll let you know once we have a decision on whether it will be released as a set!

All other projects in the Winter 2012, Spring and Summer 2013 Review periods will not be produced.

The LEGO Review Board has evaluated each project these three review periods according to our decision criteria. We’ve decided that all other concepts in the Winter 2012, Spring, and Summer 2013 periods (including the Thinking with Portals! project from the Fall 2012 period) will unfortunately not be produced as LEGO sets. Sometimes our best hopes and plans end up not working out. After a thorough evaluation, the LEGO Review Board has determined that we will not release a set based on any of these projects. We realize this is disappointing to some, so please know that this decision does not take away from the beauty and effort put into these projects by each talented LEGO fan.

Winter, Spring, & Summer LEGO Review Results

How do we make these decisions?

We know how hard you work, vote, and spread the word to see your favorite concepts become reality. Once a project reaches 10,000 supporters, our team is then responsible for deciding what sets LEGO CUUSOO will produce according to our criteria and business model.

By gaining 10,000 supporters, a fan-submitted project moves from the Idea Stage to the Review Stage, where it earns the opportunity to be considered as a future LEGO® set in a quarterly process called the “LEGO Review.” Gaining 10,000 Supporters is just the first step in this process.

During the LEGO Review, we take your vote and the the information you give us in the brief support survey into consideration. This contributes to the Review Board’s analysis of a project’s potential as a LEGO set.

The “LEGO Review Board” composed of LEGO set designers, marketing and business representatives, and other relevant team members across the LEGO Group examines each qualified project. They evaluate concept models and determine if the concept meets our high standards for what it takes to be a LEGO product; including factors such as playability, safety, and fit with the LEGO brand.

Every potential LEGO product, including those developed internally, goes through a process like this and must meet the same standards. The amount of time this takes varies due to all the factors involved, however, know that every set must be fully evaluated before we make a decision about its viability as a set.

The LEGO Review Board makes all final decisions on which new sets the LEGO Group will release based on CUUSOO projects.

Fall LEGO Review Results Coming Early 2014

The Fall 2013 Review results will be available in early 2014

We’ve already started our review of the seven projects from the Fall 2013 period, and we’ll share the results in early 2014. Our team is looking forward to bringing you the Exo Suit and considering more of your projects as they reach 10,000 supporters and qualify for review.

Happy building!

Congratulations to our three Summer Review Qualifiers!

As of 12:00 a.m. this morning, we have two three new qualifiers for the LEGO CUUSOO Summer Review. That’s right, the “League of Legends of LEGO” project reached 10k with just a couple hours to spare! Here are the projects that qualify this time:

  • Mini Shop Series – After crushing the 5,000 benchmark in late January, this project was able to reach 10,000 by April – only 19 days before this project turned one year old! This is truly an inspiration for other project creators, both in terms of design and promotion. Great work, Pekko!
  • Batmobile Tumbler Minifig Scale – BrentWaller was so inspired by the idea of a LEGO® Batmobile Tumbler that he actually painstakingly hand painted and dyed bricks to create a camouflage version to accompany the original model you’ve got to admire that kind of determination! This is truly a slick, beautiful model, and it’s just an added bonus that a LEGO Minifigure Batman can actually ride around in it.
  • League of Legends of LEGO – The Raid on Baron Nashor – Addam did an excellent job sharing concepts for LEGO sets based on the popular League of Legends game. When we asked him to focus his idea on a single concept, he rallied support and concluded with presenting the Raid on Baron Nashor as an iconic LoL scene to consider.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

But wait, what’s the Summer Review?
If you’ve missed the blog articles mentioning the review process, you should go back and focus on these three educational posts: Projects Reaching 10,000 Supporters Will Now Be Reviewed Quarterly, The Quarterly LEGO Review: How does it work?, and Cheat Sheet: How to Pass the LEGO Review with Flying Colors.

What about the other Reviews? When Will Those Results be Published?
We are currently working on the results of the Fall, Winter, and Spring Reviews. Be patient Grasshopper, and read the end of this article if you want more information on why these reviews take so long.

LEGO Review Batches in Progress

The 2013 Fall Review Deadline is September 1st
If your project didn’t quite make it this time, you can qualify if you gain 10,000 votes by 12:00 a.m. GMT September 1st. That’s just three months away, so get to it!

Just 6 Days to Qualify for the Summer 2013 LEGO Review

There are just six more days to qualify for the Summer 2013 LEGO® Review. Projects that reach 10,000 supporters by midnight (GMT) on June 3 will earn a place in this review period, alongside Mini Shop Series and Batmobile Tumbler™ Minifig Scale, to be considered as potential future LEGO sets.

How can you help your favorite project reach 10,000 supporters by June 3? Share with your friends via social networks, LEGO fan forums, and to others who can help spread the word too. Make sure you ask them to sign up and support, as that’s what will put your favorite project over the top!

Who has a shot at 10k?
Well, as the LEGO Minecraft™ and Purdue Pete™ concepts showed us, anything can happen. But here are the top 5 projects who are closest to the goal. Will one or more of them reach 10,000 in time?

  1. League of Legends of LEGO
  2. FTL: Faster Than Light
  3. Macross VF-1 Valkyrie
  4. Poptropica: Dr. Hare’s Lair
  5. LEGO Bird Series

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

LEGO Review batches begin on a quarterly basis, so projects that don’t make this cut may qualify before September 1 for the next LEGO Review.

But what about the Fall LEGO Review … you know, from last year?
While you’ve been anxiously awaiting the results of the Fall 2012 LEGO Review (and subsequent reviews, let’s be honest), our team has been considering the  UCS Sandcrawler, Mars Science Laboratory Curiosity Rover, and Thinking with Portals! projects as potential LEGO products.

The Winter and Spring LEGO Review periods are also in progress, though they’re naturally in earlier stages. Here’s a snapshot of all of the projects that have achieved 10,000 supporters and are awaiting a review decision:

LEGO Review Batches in Progress - May 28, 2013

Why does it take so long?
Since we began quarterly review batches last year, we’ve been learning that it’s difficult to give definite timeframes to expect results. Our posts on the review process present a nice framework for how we consider a project for production–but it is by no means an easy process. Ultimately, the products we release must fit our brand and strategy, have a strong business case, and a final model must fit our design, buildability, and playability standards. These factors are compounded when working with license partners, each of whom has their own terms and standards.

Projects in each quarterly review are considered in batches, so we announce the results for each project simultaneously. All three projects in the Fall 2012 review period require that we negotiate and collaborate with license partners and this adds complexity to the process. Especially in cases where we are negotiating with third parties, we won’t share news about some projects earlier than others.

We’re anxious to share the exciting news about the Fall 2012 and subsequent LEGO Review groups, and will do so when the time is right. Thanks again for your patience through the process, and stay tuned!